Study on Factors Affecting the Storage Survival Rates of Probiotic Bacteria Powder

doi:10.13560/j.cnki.biotech.bull.1985.2022-0954

Abstract

Abstract:

This work is aimed to study the factors affecting the storage activities of three types of probiotic powder, Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium and Coccus, so as to provide guidance for the quality index control and application of probiotics powder. Lactobacillus acidophilus LA85, Lactobacillus plantarum Lp90, Lactobacillus rhamnosusLRa05, Lactobacillus casei LC89, Bifidobacterium lactis BLa80, Bifidobacterium longum BL21, Bifidobacterium breve BBr60, Bifidobacterium infantis BI45, Streptococcus thermophilus ST81, Pediococcus lactis PA53, Pediococcus pentosaceus PP06, Lactococcus lactis LLa61 were used as the research objects, and the survival rates of bacteria and protease activities were used as indicators to investigate the quality indicators of probiotic bacteria powder（moisture and water activity）, storage temperature and encapsulation method on the cell survival rate and protease activity during storage. The moisture and water activity of the bacteria powder presented no significant effect on the storage survival rate and protease activity within a certain range（P<0.05）. The storage survival rate and protease activity decreased significantly（P<0.05）with the increasing of moisture and water activity while beyond a certain range. Different storage temperatures（-18℃, 4℃, and 25℃）had significant effects on the storage survival rate and protease activity of bacterial powder（P<0.05）. The survival rate of bacteria in vacuum encapsulation was better than that in ordinary encapsulation（P<0.05）. The optimal moisture content of Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium and Coccus powders, the quality control index of water activity, storage temperature and encapsulation method are determined to ensure the survival rate of probiotic powder during storage, and to provide guidance for the formulation and application of quality control standards for probiotic powder manufacturers.

Key words: moisture, water activity, Bifidobacterium, Lactobacillus, stability

YAN Tao, CHEN Ke-ke, YANG Heng-fei, ZHU Jian-guo, XIA Jiu-xue, FANG Shu-guang. Study on Factors Affecting the Storage Survival Rates of Probiotic Bacteria Powder[J]. Biotechnology Bulletin, 2023, 39(4): 296-303.

Figures/Tables 9

References 21

[1]	李晴, 唐文倩, 谢柳佳, 等. 不同壁材包埋对益生菌性能的影响[J]. 食品与发酵科技, 2020, 56(6): 92-99.
	Li Q, Tang WQ, Xie LJ, et al. Effects of different wall materials on characteristics of microencapsulated probiotics[J]. Food Ferment Sci ＆ Technol, 2020, 56(6): 92-99.
[2]	王似锦, 江志杰, 牛振东, 等. 保健食品双歧杆菌和乳酸菌计数方法的优化[J]. 中国微生态学杂志, 2015, 27(2): 227-229, 232.
	Wang SJ, Jiang ZJ, Niu ZD, et al. Optimization of enumeration method on Bifidobacteria and lactic bacteria in health food[J]. Chin J Microecol, 2015, 27(2): 227-229, 232.
[3]	Syngai GG, Gopi R, Bharali R, et al. Probiotics - the versatile functional food ingredients[J]. J Food Sci Technol, 2016, 53(2): 921-933. doi: 10.1007/s13197-015-2011-0 pmid: 27162372
[4]	贾宇, 董晨阳, 周绪宝, 等. 品质因子和益生菌对草莓品质和贮藏的影响[J]. 农产品加工, 2019(13): 12-15.
	Jia Y, Dong CY, Zhou XB, et al. Effects of quality factors and probiotics on strawberry quality and storage[J]. Farm Prod Process, 2019(13): 12-15.
[5]	Morovic W, Budinoff CR. Epigenetics: a new frontier in probiotic research[J]. Trends Microbiol, 2021, 29(2): 117-126. doi: 10.1016/j.tim.2020.04.008 pmid: 32409146
[6]	张金丽. 低水分活度食品的微生物安全研究进展[J]. 生物化工, 2017, 3(6): 89-90.
	Zhang JL. Research progress on microbial safety of low water activity foods[J]. Biol Chem Eng, 2017, 3(6): 89-90.
[7]	Sablani SS, Kasapis S, Rahman MS. Evaluating water activity and glass transition concepts for food stability[J]. J Food Eng, 2007, 78(1): 266-271. doi: 10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2005.09.025 URL
[8]	Rothrock MJ, Zhuang H, Lawrence KC, et al. In-package inactivation of pathogenic and spoilage bacteria associated with poultry using dielectric barrier discharge-cold plasma treatments[J]. Curr Microbiol, 2017, 74(2): 149-158. doi: 10.1007/s00284-016-1158-x pmid: 27885385
[9]	黄晓燕, 刘铖珺, 李长城, 等. 低水分活度食品微生物控制技术研究现状[J]. 食品与发酵工业, 2020, 46(23): 286-292.
	Huang XY, Liu CJ, Li CC, et al. Research progress in microbiological control of food with low water activity[J]. Food Ferment Ind, 2020, 46(23): 286-292.
[10]	杨红, 王锁民. 豌豆种子萌发时的含水量对子叶中蛋白酶和淀粉酶活性的影响[J]. 西北植物学报, 2002, 22(5): 1136-1142.
	Yang H, Wang SM. The effect of water content in germinating pea seeds on activities of protease and amylase in the cotyledons[J]. Acta Bot Boreali Occidentalia Sin, 2002, 22(5): 1136-1142.
[11]	黄晓辰, 蔡友华, 马金魁, 等. 发酵食品源功能活性肽及其应用研究进展[J]. 现代食品科技, 2021(8): 364-374.
	Huang XC, Cai YH, Ma JK, et al. Research progress on functional active peptides in fermented foods and their application[J]. Mod Food Sci Technol, 2021(8): 364-374.
[12]	贾宏信. 充氮包装对乳粉贮存过程中水分、水分活度及益生菌活菌数变化的影响[J]. 中国乳品工业, 2019, 47(1): 27-30.
	Jia HX. Effect of Nitrogen-filled packaging on the moisture content, water activity and viable count of probiotic milk powder during storage[J]. China Dairy Ind, 2019, 47(1): 27-30.
[13]	Remón D, Bandera YN, López FD. Preliminary analysis of the efect of water activity on viability and stability of probiotics formulations[J]. Centro Azucar, 2016, 43(1):24-30.
[14]	何光华, 姜慧萍, 黄焘, 等. 益生菌配方奶粉中水分活度的控制[J]. 中国乳品工业, 2012, 40(2): 30-32.
	He GH, Jiang HP, Huang T, et al. Controlling water activity of probiotics formula powder[J]. China Dairy Ind, 2012, 40(2): 30-32.
[15]	Akkermans S, Noriega Fernandez E, Logist F, et al. Introducing a novel interaction model structure for the combined effect of temperature and pH on the microbial growth rate[J]. Int J Food Microbiol, 2017, 240: 85-96. doi: S0168-1605(16)30304-X pmid: 27393390
[16]	陈琳, 周光宏, 徐幸莲, 等. 高氧气调包装对宰后猪肉蛋白质氧化、钙蛋白酶活性及蛋白质降解的影响[J]. 中国农业科学, 2016, 49(18): 3628-3638. doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2016.18.017
	Chen L, Zhou GH, Xu XL, et al. Effects of high oxygen modified atmosphere packaging on protein oxidation, calpain activity and protein proteolysis of pork during postmortem refrigerated storage[J]. Sci Agric Sin, 2016, 49(18): 3628-3638. doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2016.18.017
[17]	宋士良. 微包埋技术及其在益生菌中应用现状综述[J]. 中国饲料添加剂, 2021(8): 12-19.
	Song SL. Review of microencapsulation technology and its application in probiotics[J]. China Feed Addit, 2021(8): 12-19.
[18]	Cook MT, Tzortzis G, Charalampopoulos D, et al. Microencapsulation of probiotics for gastrointestinal delivery[J]. J Control Release, 2012, 162(1): 56-67. doi: 10.1016/j.jconrel.2012.06.003 URL
[19]	满丽莉, 向殿军, 布日额, 等. 乳酸菌的热胁迫研究进展[J]. 现代食品科技, 2019, 35(1): 281-287.
	Man LL, Xiang DJ, Bu RE, et al. Research progress on heat stress of lactic acid bacteria[J]. Mod Food Sci Technol, 2019, 35(1): 281-287.
[20]	Talwalkar A, Kailasapathy K, Peiris P, et al. Application of RBGR—a simple way for screening of oxygen tolerance in probiotic bacteria[J]. Int J Food Microbiol, 2001, 71(2/3): 245-248. doi: 10.1016/S0168-1605(01)00563-3 URL
[21]	Hoover R, Manuel H. Effect of heat—moisture treatment on the structure and physicochemical properties of legume starches[J]. Food Res Int, 1996, 29(8): 731-750. doi: 10.1016/S0963-9969(97)86873-1 URL

菌株Strain		批次1 Batch 1		批次2 Batch 2		批次3 Batch 3		批次4 Batch 4		批次5 Batch 5
菌株Strain		水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分 Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）
乳杆菌类Lactobacillus	LA85	2.70±0.21	0.061±0.004	3.57±0.22	0.093±0.005	5.18±0.23	0.123±0.006	5.68±0.25	0.228±0.007	6.78±0.26	0.292±0.008
	Lp90	2.97±0.11	0.059±0.001	3.60±0.12	0.078±0.002	5.20±0.13	0.128±0.003	5.80±0.14	0.152±0.004	6.61±0.15	0.180±0.005
	LRa05	2.78±0.09	0.064±0.003	3.86±0.11	0.099±0.004	5.58±0.13	0.131±0.005	6.78±0.15	0.151±0.006	7.04±0.16	0.251±0.007
	LC89	3.08±0.10	0.060±0.004	3.44±0.12	0.068±0.005	5.16±0.13	0.126±0.006	5.51±0.15	0.154±0.007	6.56±0.17	0.175±0.008
双歧杆菌类Bifidobacterium	BLa80	3.26±0.13	0.057±0.012	4.86±0.15	0.079±0.013	5.00±0.16	0.120±0.014	5.58±0.17	0.140±0.015	6.27±0.18	0.160±0.016
	BL21	3.08±0.11	0.064±0.008	4.65±0.12	0.089±0.009	5.01±0.13	0.121±0.010	5.58±0.14	0.138±0.011	6.86±0.15	0.148±0.012
	BBr60	3.04±0.16	0.067±0.017	4.31±0.18	0.091±0.018	5.08±0.19	0.125±0.019	5.59±0.20	0.130±0.020	6.79±0.22	0.145±0.022
	BI45	3.12±0.17	0.070±0.003	4.31±0.19	0.098±0.005	5.07±0.20	0.128±0.005	5.55±0.21	0.131±0.006	6.89±0.25	0.149±0.007
球菌类Cocci	ST81	2.52±0.08	0.051±0.004	3.07±0.09	0.085±0.005	5.15±0.10	0.127±0.006	5.55±0.11	0.134±0.007	6.48±0.13	0.143±0.008
	PA53	2.90±0.09	0.058±0.011	3.65±0.10	0.088±0.012	5.18±0.11	0.127±0.013	5.56±0.12	0.138±0.014	6.79±0.14	0.141±0.015
	PP06	2.95±0.18	0.070±0.002	3.78±0.19	0.090±0.003	5.38±0.20	0.128±0.004	5.66±0.21	0.130±0.005	6.81±0.23	0.136±0.006
	LLa61	2.62±0.16	0.063±0.003	3.08±0.18	0.089±0.004	5.20±0.19	0.129±0.005	5.79±0.21	0.134±0.006	6.30±0.23	0.139±0.007

菌株Strain		批次1 Batch 1		批次2 Batch 2		批次3 Batch 3		批次4 Batch 4		批次5 Batch 5
菌株Strain		水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）	水分 Moisture/%	水分活度Water activity（Aw）
乳杆菌类Lactobacillus	LA85	2.70±0.21	0.061±0.004	3.57±0.22	0.093±0.005	5.18±0.23	0.123±0.006	5.68±0.25	0.228±0.007	6.78±0.26	0.292±0.008
	Lp90	2.97±0.11	0.059±0.001	3.60±0.12	0.078±0.002	5.20±0.13	0.128±0.003	5.80±0.14	0.152±0.004	6.61±0.15	0.180±0.005
	LRa05	2.78±0.09	0.064±0.003	3.86±0.11	0.099±0.004	5.58±0.13	0.131±0.005	6.78±0.15	0.151±0.006	7.04±0.16	0.251±0.007
	LC89	3.08±0.10	0.060±0.004	3.44±0.12	0.068±0.005	5.16±0.13	0.126±0.006	5.51±0.15	0.154±0.007	6.56±0.17	0.175±0.008
双歧杆菌类Bifidobacterium	BLa80	3.26±0.13	0.057±0.012	4.86±0.15	0.079±0.013	5.00±0.16	0.120±0.014	5.58±0.17	0.140±0.015	6.27±0.18	0.160±0.016
	BL21	3.08±0.11	0.064±0.008	4.65±0.12	0.089±0.009	5.01±0.13	0.121±0.010	5.58±0.14	0.138±0.011	6.86±0.15	0.148±0.012
	BBr60	3.04±0.16	0.067±0.017	4.31±0.18	0.091±0.018	5.08±0.19	0.125±0.019	5.59±0.20	0.130±0.020	6.79±0.22	0.145±0.022
	BI45	3.12±0.17	0.070±0.003	4.31±0.19	0.098±0.005	5.07±0.20	0.128±0.005	5.55±0.21	0.131±0.006	6.89±0.25	0.149±0.007
球菌类Cocci	ST81	2.52±0.08	0.051±0.004	3.07±0.09	0.085±0.005	5.15±0.10	0.127±0.006	5.55±0.11	0.134±0.007	6.48±0.13	0.143±0.008
	PA53	2.90±0.09	0.058±0.011	3.65±0.10	0.088±0.012	5.18±0.11	0.127±0.013	5.56±0.12	0.138±0.014	6.79±0.14	0.141±0.015
	PP06	2.95±0.18	0.070±0.002	3.78±0.19	0.090±0.003	5.38±0.20	0.128±0.004	5.66±0.21	0.130±0.005	6.81±0.23	0.136±0.006
	LLa61	2.62±0.16	0.063±0.003	3.08±0.18	0.089±0.004	5.20±0.19	0.129±0.005	5.79±0.21	0.134±0.006	6.30±0.23	0.139±0.007

分类Classification	菌株Strain	存活率Survival rate/%
分类Classification	菌株Strain	批次1 Batch 1	批次2 Batch 2	批次3 Batch 3	批次4 Batch 4	批次5 Batch 5
乳杆菌Lactobacillus	LA85	93.43±1.43	92.23±2.11	91.54±1.91	85.23±1.31*	80.43±1.67**
	Lp90	96.32±1.67	95.89±2.01	94.43±1.54	88.32±1.54*	83.32±1.34**
	LRa05	95.67±1.21	94.65±1.81	93.87±1.44	86.32±1.67*	81.43±2.34**
	LC89	92.54±1.67	92.34±1.56	91.67±1.89	83.44±1.32*	77.34±1.43**
双歧杆菌Bifidobacterium	BLa80	97.45±1.35	96.41±1.55	95.32±1.68	90.43±1.11*	84.32±1.11**
	BL21	96.65±1.22	95.12±1.67	95.31±1.44	90.32±1.56*	83.21±1.51**
	BBr60	95.44±1.57	94.11±1.35	93.32±1.68	88.32±1.56*	82.77±1.88**
	BI45	93.14±1.01	92.35±1.45	92.88±1.54	86.32±1.58*	80.55±1.22**
球菌 Cocci	ST81	92.55±1.65	91.78±1.23	91.11±1.63	85.34±1.51*	80.69±1.51**
	PA53	92.67±1.64	91.77±1.88	90.88±1.13	85.99±1.99*	80.01±1.67**
	PP06	92.33±1.54	92.11±1.33	91.76±2.13	86.11±1.78*	81.35±1.32**
	LLa61	88.18±1.48	87.44±1.54	86.89±1.56	80.23±1.65*	74.67±1.78**

分类Classification	菌株Strain	存活率Survival rate/%
分类Classification	菌株Strain	批次1 Batch 1	批次2 Batch 2	批次3 Batch 3	批次4 Batch 4	批次5 Batch 5
乳杆菌Lactobacillus	LA85	93.43±1.43	92.23±2.11	91.54±1.91	85.23±1.31*	80.43±1.67**
	Lp90	96.32±1.67	95.89±2.01	94.43±1.54	88.32±1.54*	83.32±1.34**
	LRa05	95.67±1.21	94.65±1.81	93.87±1.44	86.32±1.67*	81.43±2.34**
	LC89	92.54±1.67	92.34±1.56	91.67±1.89	83.44±1.32*	77.34±1.43**
双歧杆菌Bifidobacterium	BLa80	97.45±1.35	96.41±1.55	95.32±1.68	90.43±1.11*	84.32±1.11**
	BL21	96.65±1.22	95.12±1.67	95.31±1.44	90.32±1.56*	83.21±1.51**
	BBr60	95.44±1.57	94.11±1.35	93.32±1.68	88.32±1.56*	82.77±1.88**
	BI45	93.14±1.01	92.35±1.45	92.88±1.54	86.32±1.58*	80.55±1.22**
球菌 Cocci	ST81	92.55±1.65	91.78±1.23	91.11±1.63	85.34±1.51*	80.69±1.51**
	PA53	92.67±1.64	91.77±1.88	90.88±1.13	85.99±1.99*	80.01±1.67**
	PP06	92.33±1.54	92.11±1.33	91.76±2.13	86.11±1.78*	81.35±1.32**
	LLa61	88.18±1.48	87.44±1.54	86.89±1.56	80.23±1.65*	74.67±1.78**

分类Classification	菌株Strain	存活率Survival rate/%
分类Classification	菌株Strain	贮存-18℃Storage at -18℃	贮存4℃Storage at 4℃	贮存25℃Storage at 25℃
乳杆菌 Lactobacillus	LA85	92.23±2.11	79.34±1.91**	48.56±2.67**
	Lp90	95.12±1.81	84.34±1.22**	44.31±1.79**
	LRa05	93.33±1.22	83.23±1.87**	40.36±1.64**
	LC89	90.01±1.12	82.15±1.85**	43.43±1.57**
双歧杆菌 Bifidobacterium	BLa80	94.45±1.32	84.54±1.67**	49.33±1.67**
	BL21	92.65±1.32	78.24±1.86**	31.35±1.65**
	BBr60	92.67±1.33	82.34±1.66**	36.34±2.66**
	BI45	94.54±1.45	79.11±1.89**	26.24±1.76**
球菌 Cocci	ST81	90.45±1.55	72.11±2.89**	43.33±1.67**
	PA53	91.20±1.01	72.45±1.55**	33.34±1.66**
	PP06	90.03±1.06	78.13±1.97**	45.33±1.67**
	LLa61	86.78±1.22	71.43±1.57**	43.53±2.47**